FANDOM


  • Superbike10
    Superbike10 closed this thread because:
    Suggestion Over
    17:39, June 8, 2017
    Suggestion
    Suggestion
    This is a suggestion for the wiki. When voting on it, type out the
    Support Support template if you support the idea,
    Oppose Oppose template if you oppose the idea, or
    Neutral Neutral template if you're undecided and/or indifferent.
    If you are unsure of what is being suggested, please refrain from voting until you fully understand, by asking questions, what is being suggested.
    To stay consistent with the wiki's style of images, I suggest that we replace all ten of the reboot aliens' infobox image. Furthermore, they are accurate to the reboot's color palette and shows all their details, as they are not posing and facing forward. However, someone needs to clean up the cropping.
    Profile Upgrade RB
    Upgrade re
    GrowingPains38

    Voting ends June 8.

    For your vote to be counted, you must type out one of the three templates in source mode.
    {{Support}}, {{Neutral}} or {{Oppose}}
    You have to have been a member of the wiki for at least 7 days with at least 15 quality mainspace edits in total (excluding minor edits) and have at least 5 contributions within the past two months to be eligible for voting.
      Loading editor
    • Support Support

        Loading editor
    • Neutral Neutral

        Loading editor
    • Oppose Oppose

        Loading editor
    • As I have told you earlier, the wiki prefers action poses over standing ones. But anyway, its a voting so that could change.

      btw, I guess you mean the voting ends on June 8, not January 8.

        Loading editor
    • While I prefer standing poses to action poses, I also prefer 3/4 angles to perfect front views. So I have voted against this.

        Loading editor
    • Shocker03 wrote:
      As I have told you earlier, the wiki prefers action poses over standing ones. But anyway, its a voting so that could change.

      No, this is not true, like at all. We only use action poses when there are no standing poses available for the aliens. or if the standing pose is too small, if you go pretty much any alien page, you can find a standing pose. For instance, Ultimate Humungousaur or Swampfire.

      I have no idea where you get this idea from, or what gives you the privellege to make up the rules.

        Loading editor
    • Echoson wrote: I have no idea where you get this idea from, or what gives you the privellege to make up the rules.

      That was my general understanding because on some articles, while I was on this wiki back in 2014, the regular poses were changed for action poses. I may have been mistaken. It could have been done because of the reasons you mentioned. My bad. Its not like I am making anything up.

        Loading editor
    • Can anyone really clear up which pose is majority?

        Loading editor
    • Shocker03 wrote:

      That was my general understanding because on some articles, while I was on this wiki back in 2014, the regular poses were changed for action poses. I may have been mistaken. It could have been done because of the reasons you mentioned. My bad. Its not like I am making anything up.

      Oh, okay then. Also sorry if I offended you, that wasn't my intention. And thanks for the heads up on the date!

        Loading editor
    • Echoson wrote:

      Shocker03 wrote:

      That was my general understanding because on some articles, while I was on this wiki back in 2014, the regular poses were changed for action poses. I may have been mistaken. It could have been done because of the reasons you mentioned. My bad. Its not like I am making anything up.

      Oh, okay then. Also sorry if I offended you, that wasn't my intention. And thanks for the heads up on the date!

      No no, I never felt offended. I just wanted to clarify my side, as to why I thought that was the rule. :)

        Loading editor
    • Trigger009
      Trigger009 removed this reply because:
      Invalid vote
      22:43, June 6, 2017
      This reply has been removed
    • Action poses are more visually appealing and neater than flat models.

        Loading editor
    • Trigger009
      Trigger009 removed this reply because:
      Invalid vote
      00:02, June 7, 2017
      This reply has been removed
    • PassportPortpass wrote:
      Action poses are more visually appealling and neater than flat models.

      Yeah, thing is though, action poses usually cover up/make certIain body not easy to see due to the angle, which is probably why the wiki prefers standing art work where we get to see them from the side compared to action poses. Plus, these images are color accurate to the show, unlike the action poses.

        Loading editor
    • PassportPortpass wrote: Action poses are more visually appealling and neater than flat models.

      I agree.

      Echoson wrote: Yeah, thing is though, action poses usually cover up/make certIain body not easy to see due to the angle, which is probably why the wiki prefers standing art work where we get to see them from the side compared to action poses. Plus, these images are color accurate to the show, unlike the action poses.

      About the colour accuracy, well, there are some articles in the wiki which use images in their infobox that aren't fully colour accurate and/or have missing shadows etc. Plus, the images used currently aren't really dramatic. They are mostly standing with just a slight angle tilt.

        Loading editor
    • My problem with the standing pictures is that they have green lines all over around them. It looks messy. I'm surprised no one else noticed.

        Loading editor
    • MizukageMoonstone wrote:
      My problem with the standing pictures is that they have green lines all over around them. It looks messy. I'm surprised no one else noticed.


      Everyone noticed. The original post says "However, someone needs to clean up the cropping."

        Loading editor
    • Shocker03 wrote:
      About the colour accuracy, well, there are some articles in the wiki which use images in their infobox that aren't fully colour accurate and/or have missing shadows etc. Plus, the images used currently aren't really dramatic. They are mostly standing with just a slight angle tilt.

      Which articles have images that doesn't have shadows? Those images do not suit articles at all, and misrepresent what they look like in the show.

        Loading editor
    • As of now I remember Shocksquatch and Ben Tennyson (OS). But I think there were more.

        Loading editor
    • Shocker03 wrote: As of now I remember Shocksquatch and Ben Tennyson (OS). But I think there were more.

      I suggest replacing the Shocksquatch image with this.
      ShocksquatchAlien

      It's a quite dramatic action pose but that's the best we have got.

        Loading editor
    • 7 days are over. The final score is:

      • 4 supports
      • 4 opposes
      • 2 neutrals

      The suggestion has ended in a tie. The administrators will now discuss it.

      If it is decided, however, that the images should be replaced, it should only be done when the cropping is cleaned up, as per the basis of the suggestion.

        Loading editor
Give Kudos to this message
You've given this message Kudos!
See who gave Kudos to this message
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.