|This article belongs to the Race Against Time timeline in the Classic Continuity|
|This section needs expansion. You can help by adding information.|
It appears in the first instance, when it is sent by Max along with other Plumbers to take care that Eon does not approach Ben. Ben says: "even Mrs. Carlyle and her plants", so it is believed that she takes care of her plants, that she sells them or both. She is the only one who was not locked up by Eon, he is seen in the final scene of the film when Ben says that everything returns to normal, she appears sitting on a bench with a hat and glasses (which she did not have before) and smiling like forever. She, along with Mr. Jenyx and Mr. Enguells, do not say a word. Curiously, they are the last Plumbers to make their debut in that movie.
- Ben 10: Race Against Time (first appearance)