Board Thread:News and Announcements/@comment-34326521-20141123083842/@comment-34326521-20141123091029

Echoson wrote: Blaziken rjcf wrote: Echoson wrote: Yeah... I don't really like this idea. You should have really made that a suggestion for the wiki to discuss, because I prefer people to give me reasons why they oppose or support. It was discussed by the CotG, and most users don't give reasons anyhow. Key word: Most.

Usually when I make suggestions, I tell everyone to give a reason before voting. This system might as well been the usually voting template: Do you like pie? Yes No That system allows for anonymous voting and does not indicate who voted, making the account requirements irrelevant. As for asking them to give reasons, that's not a requirement for voting, so it wasn't taken into account. I also doubt it works.